• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Women's Executive Board

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Membership
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Member Login
    • Home
    • About Us
    • Membership
    • Blog
    • Contact Us
    • Member Login
Back to Blog

Why Leadership Development Programs Aren’t Developing Leaders

Leadership Development can be generally defined as any activity that enhances the quality of leadership within an organization. It seems like a simple concept, but all too often leadership development fails because of it’s inherently loose meaning and lack of measurable outcomes.

For example, leadership development could refer to individuals trying to better themselves, or leaders attempting to develop their employees for reasons such as succession planning. This has created a booming industry. Last year alone, American organizations spent “ approximately $164.2 billion on [development]. Of this total direct learning expenditure, 61 percent ($100.2 billion) was spent internally.

The remainder was spent on external services, which accounted for 28 percent ($46 billion); and tuition reimbursement accounted for 11 percent ($18 billion),” according to an ASTD study. Interest in the area of leadership development has exploded in the past 20 years, and yet programs meant to develop leadership continue to fall short of what they are intended to accomplish. Why is that?

Not only is the term defined broadly, but individuals seeking leadership development often confuse it for management training and overlook context.On top of that, they do not decouple learning and reflection from actual, hands-on work experience, nor do they continually measure results or assess the proper mindset. All of these add up to a gigantic op when it comes to effective leadership development.

$164.2 billion amount American organizations spent on development last year$100.2 billion spent on internal services

$46 billion spent on external services

$18 billion spent on tuition reimbursement

Self-Reflection

Perhaps the hardest part about developing a leader (yourself or others) is understanding one must change their behavior before they can change their leadership abilities. It seems obvious enough, but in order to change behavior, mindset has to be altered as well. Moreover, developing yourself should feel uncomfortable.

A better analogy may be that of an athlete. An athlete in training will feel muscle discomfort. They should. As an athlete struggles to get stronger, faster, etc., they will feel the pains of development. So should a leader in regard to their performance.

It’s not always easy. As one McKinsey report stated,

Identifying some of the deepest, ‘below the surface’ thoughts, feelings, assumptions, and beliefs is usually a precondition of behavioral change — one too often shirked in development programs.

Promoting the virtues of delegation and empowerment, for example, is fine in theory, but successful adoption is unlikely if the program participants have a clear “controlling” mind-set. It’s true that some personality traits (such as extrover- sion or introversion) are difficult to shift, but people can change the way they see the world and their values.

According to “Leadership Charisma,” an extremely helpful book for those seeking leadership development, good leadership “is simply a question of behavior.”

Becoming a charismatic leader begins with this critical first step — the decision to commit to the development of behaviors that will drive your leadership charisma higher, and bring you the results achieved only by those charismatic leaders who inspire their people to greater levels of engagement and productivity.

The book further points out that the most important choice is to commit. It may not be easy, and may feel uncomfortable, but truly committing to leadership development is the only e ective way to see results, and those results will pay off in time.

Measuring Results

Coming back to the athlete, what good is practice if the results aren’t measured? How would they know if they’re jumping higher, running faster, or lifting a heavier weight if they are not comparing it against previous records and individuals? The same principle applies to leadership development.

Too often, individuals and organizations talk a big game about developing leadership — investing nothing more than lip service — but never follow through or quantify the results. Another issue arises when the evaluation of leadership development begins and ends with participant feedback. When this occurs, the program is often revised to suit the participants and provide a more pleasant delivery. Again, development should be uncomfortable, but using the right tools can make it easier.

One of the best ways to quantifiably measure leadership development is to implement a 360-degree leadership assessment tool to help managers identify and prioritize their own development opportunities and leadership skills.

Effective leaders are essential for maintaining a successful company. You need to ensure that your leaders grow and constantly improve. Leadership assessment solutions can help you understand where leaders need support and training — and can suggest the best ways to motivate and encourage these employees.

A 360° leadership assessment tool allows you to assess leadership skills within your company and see aggregated data to help create effective tailored development initiatives. The data generated in the assessment report provides measurable recommendations of tactics that can improve leadership skills and enhance professional development.

Original article posted on Medium

Previous Post
Leading with Vision — Spotlight on Bonnie Hagemann, CEO @ Executive Development Associates

This amazing group of women has become an important part of my life, both personally and professionally! I love the mentorship of the group and the benefit of taking away different lessons from each perspective.

Allison Dickens, Owner, Ludger's Bavarian Cakery

Being an entrepreneur can be a scary road for what lies ahead. However, being with a group of entrepreneurs walking the same road that helps you devise a plan for the unknown and to revel in the joy…well that is WEB.

Tani Kelley, Advertising Specialties and Spirit Accessories, President and Owner

I joined WEB with the hope of networking with other women in leadership roles. But what I get out of it is vastly more. I have relationships with a trusted group of mentors that inspire me and provide guidance and support in all aspects of life. My confidence in my problem solving and leadership has grown exponentially through the ability to present specific business challenges and receive constructive feedback and guidance. WEB provides a safe environment along with the support and encouragement needed to continually work on my personal and emotional growth. As a result WEB is an essential component for achieving my professional and personal goals.

Sarah Fields, President, Jetta Corporation

As you move higher up in an organization, you find yourself is a somewhat lonely position. You aren’t always certain who to trust and often you can get caught up in your own perceptions of issues. WEB has allowed me to work through some of my most complex and passion-filled challenges in a safe and accountable environment. The women in WEB hold me to my highest standard; value the trust of the organization; and have impacted my business in a positive and lucrative manner. WEB is the best investment I have made in my personal and professional self in the last 15 years. It makes the budget every year because the ROI can’t be beat.

Ashley K. Perkins, Vice President, Omaha/Sun Valley, Cox Business

WEB is a wonderful opportunity to network and collaborate with other executive women in many industries. Sharing real personal and professional challenges with an intimate group of trusted executive women who experience similar trials in their profession each day has become an important part of my own growth and my decision-making process- I learn as I share, and I learn just as much from the experiences of others.

Sara Tsoodle, VP of Client Services & Operations, Tricorps Technologies

I joined WEB while my business was small, and my knowledge of business ownership was limited. The founder, Lynn Flinn is insightful, and her business acumen and savvy are unmatched. She is one of the most influential and community-focused leaders in Tulsa. Through her leadership at WEB, women are learning to grow their businesses, lead effectively, deal with difficult situations, and pursue excellence and balance. The women in the group serve as a type of advisory board to your business. Because of the WEB group, my business has grown from one to fifteen employees, my client list has grown, and I am a more confident professional.

Angela Byers, Owner, Byers Creative

WEB is a safe and comfortable environment to share your business’s successes and challenges. To me, this organization serves as my unofficial board of directors. As such, they are an integral part of my planning, goal setting, and strategic business decision making process.

Managing Partner, real estate investment firm

“It’s lonely at the top” is more true than I thought before joining WEB. Being able to share problems and opportunities in a small, trusted setting of other women leaders has been enriching in my business and personal life. This has been true in surprisingly different ways … smart women from completely different backgrounds can still provide a wealth of advice, related experiences and encouragement … finding like situations among other women in leadership and benefitting from those … making lifelong friends … the small groups and retreats provide bonding opportunities unlike any other group I’ve joined.

Pleased and rewarded to have been a member from Day 1.

Joyce Madewell, Executive Vice President, SpiritBank

Ready to step up your game?

Apply for Membership

© 2023 Women's Executive Board. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy.